Real Innovation: Loading a ship by hand in 1956: $5.86 a ton. Loading it in boxes: 16 cents.
Hi from Rotterdam. Derek here.
I'm at Intermodal Europe this week, and it's day two today. Two days of boxes, reefers, trackers and a lot of coffee. I'll tell you properly what I heard next week, because it deserves its own issue.
This week is about something nearly every one of you will face at some point. Your software vendor changes the price. What now?
New here, or missed it? Your free Day 90 Pre-Mortem Kit is waiting: the one-hour exercise to run with your team before you sign, plus 10 questions to put to any vendor. Get the kit →
About a four-minute read.
In today's Day 90:
The Day 90 Question: what would it cost to leave?
Peer poll: could you get your data out tomorrow?
Keep, fix or replace: what to do when the price goes up
Case study: the trucker who gave away the shipping container
One thing for a Wednesday: six checks before you renew
News: the freezer hacks, and what they mean for your renewals
1. The Day 90 Question
"If this vendor doubled the price in year three, what would it cost us to leave? Or could we live with it? Stress-test it."
Ask it before you sign. Nobody asks it then, and that's exactly when you have the most say.
2. This week's peer poll
If you had to leave your main system tomorrow, could you get all your data out?
One click, ten seconds. It's check number 2 below, and I suspect most of us have never tested it. I'll share the results next week.
3. Your vendor just raised the price. Keep, fix or replace?
I spent an hour on the phone recently with a forwarder who's had enough of her software bills. She's not alone. Sooner or later, every one of us gets the email. Look at the AI tools we all use now as an everyday example. How long before they get more expensive, once they're ingrained in our work and our lives and we have no real choice?
Short answer: don't jump straight to replacing it. Work through three options, in order.
Keep it if it still does a job nothing else can, at a price you can live with. This is where the Pre-Mortem comes in. Did you stress-test the price when you signed?
Fix it if the system works but the bill doesn't. Most of the savings are here: cut what you don't use, change how you use it, renegotiate. Make the system work harder for you. Challenge the supplier.
Replace it only if the cost has outgrown the value and you can staff a proper migration. A rushed switch costs more than the price rise ever will. So take a breath. It might even be an opportunity.
The answer depends on how deep you are in. A forwarder using two modules has options. A terminal whose gate, yard and billing all run on one system has far fewer.
Watch the shape of the change, too. A straight price rise is easy to see. A new pricing model is harder: paying by usage instead of a flat fee, say, or features you used to get quietly moving into a paid tier. With those, the bill depends on how you use the system, so model it on your own volumes before you agree to anything. And check how long that pricing is guaranteed for.
4. Case study: who invented the shipping container?

In 1935, Malcom McLean bought a used truck in North Carolina and started hauling empty tobacco barrels. Twenty years later he ran one of the biggest trucking firms in the US, and he had one big frustration: the hours his trucks lost waiting at the docks while cargo was loaded by hand, one sack and crate at a time.
Then came the ship. In 1955 he bought an old Second World War tanker, the Potrero Hills, had a frame built over her deck and renamed her the Ideal-X. On 26 April 1956 she left Port Newark for Houston with 58 boxes on deck. A crane lifted one aboard about every seven minutes, and she sailed the same day. In Houston, 58 trucks were waiting to take them away.
Loading by hand cost $5.86 a ton. Loading the boxes cost 16 cents.

Ideal X
A year and a half later, on 4 October 1957, the Gateway City left Newark with 226 boxes stacked in cells built into the hull and her own cranes on deck. That's the first proper container ship, and it sailed the same day the Soviets launched Sputnik.
And here's one for this week. In April 1966, her sister ship, the Fairland, started the first transatlantic container service. Destination: Rotterdam. Sixty years on, I'm writing this on board the SS Rotterdam, Holland America Line's 1959 flagship, now a hotel in the port. She's from the same era as the Ideal-X, with the opposite ending. The Ideal-X was scrapped in 1964. The Rotterdam sailed on for decades as a cruise ship, and now she's a hotel.
Jets finished off the great passenger liners. The box did the same to the old cargo ships.

Here's the bit I love. McLean could have locked everyone into his design. Instead he made his container patents available royalty-free through the International Organization for Standardization. A box that fit everyone's cranes, ships and trucks did more for his business than any licence fee. In 1969 he sold Sea-Land to R.J. Reynolds for $530 million.
Then the fall. In 1978 he bought United States Lines and built big, slow, fuel-efficient ships, betting oil would stay expensive. It didn't. Cheap oil favoured faster ships, and the company went bankrupt in 1986.
Two lessons for anyone signing a tech contract this year:
Open standards grow the whole market. Lock-in grows one vendor's margins, for a while.
Never bet the whole fleet on one assumption. Ask what happens if the price, the volume or the vendor changes.
5. One thing for a Wednesday: six checks before you renew

Pull out your contract and check these six. It takes an hour, and it's the best hour you'll spend before a renewal.
How can the price change? Look for the clause. Is there a cap, a notice period or a link to inflation? Or can they change the model completely?
Can you get all your data out? In full, in a format another system can read, at any time, not just at exit.
What would leaving really take? Notice period, exit help, and who owns any custom work.
What are you paying for and not using? Modules, users, automations, add-ons. This is usually where the quick savings are.
Who else could do the job? You don't have to switch. Knowing your options gives you a stronger hand in the renewal talk.
When does support stop? Security updates and patches, by date. Kit that stops getting updates is the kit that gets hacked.
If you can't answer 2, 3 or 6, that's your risk. Fix it at the next renewal, while you still have something they want.
6. News worth your five minutes
France blames Iran for the freezer hacks. Internet-connected refrigeration controllers in supermarkets across Europe, and a French blood bank, were hit in two waves in October and early November. Some units no longer got security updates. (TechCrunch, 9 November) Read more →
The US warns of an "ongoing cyber threat" to cold chain systems. The joint warning names transport and medicine shipping. The advice: take remote controls off the internet and retire kit that no longer gets updates. (TechCrunch, 5 November) Read more →
The freezer units had stopped getting security updates. That's a renewal question too, so I've added it to this week's checks: when do updates stop?
That's a wrap
Hit reply and tell me: has a vendor ever changed the price on you mid-contract? I read every reply, and the best ones (anonymised) go into a future issue. The views are my own.
Know someone with a renewal coming up? Forward this. They can join at flow.workdatahq.com/join and get the Pre-Mortem Kit free.
Next week: what I heard in Rotterdam. Every session came back to the same problem, and it wasn't the tech. Durban at Day 90 follows the week after.
Fair winds and following seas,
Derek
About the author: Derek O'Sullivan writes Day 90, a free weekly for people buying and running logistics tech. He started out designing container cranes at Liebherr and has spent his career on the rollout side of the industry. Day 90 is independent: no vendor pays to be in it. And his views are his own.
